Skip to Content

Our Fudge

Build a Box!

Our fudge comes in 1 1/2 pound or 3 pound boxes. Mix and match or fill with your favorite flavor!

1. Select your box
  • 1½ Pound Box
    1 1/2 Pound Box 3 delicious slices $22.45
    Select
  • 3 Pound Box
    3 Pound Box 6 decadent slices $44.85
    Select

Our Flavors

Close
Prev Next
Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate Pecan

Chocolate Pecan fudge is our most popular flavor with its smooth chocolate base packed full of crunchy pecans. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, pecans, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate No Nut

Chocolate No-Nut fudge is the perfect combination of chocolates to create a decadent chocolate experience. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Turtle

Turtle fudge takes one of our favorite candies and turns it into a gourmet fudge treat. Our chocolate pecan fudge is topped with a generous layer of buttery caramel and more crunchy pecans. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, pecans, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Oreo

Our Oreo fudge combines the delicious Oreo cookie with our decadent chocolate no-nut fudge for a unique cookies & cream experience. Topped with a white chocolate drizzle and more Oreo cookie crumbles, this fudge is sure to please any Oreo cookie lover. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chocolate Peanut Butter fudge is the answer for anyone who loves the unbeatable combination of chocolate and peanut butter. Our decadent chocolate fudge is combined with creamy peanut butter and peanut butter chips and then topped with more peanut butter chips to finish. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, peanut butter, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter fudge is the ultimate peanut butter delight. Our delectable fudge is prepared with creamy peanut butter, peanut butter chips and then topped with more peanut butter chips to finish. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with peanut butter, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate Macadamia

Chocolate Macadamia is a classic pairing of our luscious chocolate fudge and rich Macadamia nuts. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, Macadamia nuts, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

German Chocolate

German Chocolate fudge captures the essence of the classic dessert in our delicious fudge. Our chocolate pecan fudge is topped with a generous layer of buttery caramel, more crunchy pecans and a scrumptious coconut topping. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium chocolate, pecans, fresh coconut, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Maple Pecan

Maple Pecan fudge is the ideal maple indulgence. Our delectable fudge is prepared with pure maple and crunchy pecans. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium pecans, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Vanilla Pecan

Vanilla Pecan fudge is the definitive vanilla delicacy. Our delectable fudge is prepared with pure vanilla and crunchy pecans. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium pecans, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box
Chocolate Walnut

Pumpkin

Pumpkin fudge is our newest flavor and the perfect addition to your holiday table. We utilize fresh pumpkin and all the traditional spices along with a crunchy, candied pecan topping. Made by hand using traditional copper kettles and marble slabs, we begin with premium pecans, pumpkin, heavy cream and pure sugar to create the richest and creamiest fudge on Mackinac Island.

To buy this flavor, first select a box size: 1.5lb (3 slices) or 3lb (6 slices)

+ add to my box

Back to top